Gallagher points out the inability for students to develop "flow" when teachers are overteaching the texts, but another point that Gallagher should've made is that when teachers break up texts and teach them in such a formulaic manner, you only receive formulaic responses. You completely deprive your students of the ability to go deeper or anaylyze a text on their own.
The way Gallagher had his students examine and translate the scene in "Hamlet" was inspiring. Further, this was not something that I could not do with a difficult text to make it more accessible for my students.
I think my favorite suggestion he makes throughout this chapter is the one-pager. Like he says, "What I have found, however, especially with reluctant readers, is that accountability is needed" (82). This is something that I struggle with in my classroom, and throughout the book, thus far, as Gallagher has spoke of students reading for pleasure, I knew that could only be an option for half of my class unless there was some form of accountability. The one-pager is the ideal amount of accountability in that it isn't testing the student, but just asking for a reasonable amount of information that would be gained by reading.

To switch gears, the topic of my inquiry project is the interrelatedness of reading and writing in the curriculum. I find that overwhelmingly the standards for Reading and Writing are taught in isolation or with little overlap despite evidence that students who read more write better, and vice versa. Still, schools tend to focus on their reading scores, while writing scores lag behind. I would like to know how I can teach both subjects together to enhance my students understanding in both areas. Further, if this is more effective, I want to know why this sort of teaching isn't the standard teaching practice in schools.
Please give me any ideas, criticism or input on the topic as I move forward with my topic.

Jessica, I really enjoyed your rather irreverent comments--"if you only want to make students who enjoy reading"--at least, I sensed a bit of sardonic humor in this. It's so true: reading for pleasure is fine, but within the constrictions of the "system" within which we work today, there's scarcely the time. Gallagher's point (82) that "young readers need a balance of reading between academic and recreational texts," strikes me as pretty compelling within the full context of his argument. While "balance" may be a key element in all of this, try challenging the DOE standards with this "sentiment." I'm looking forward to your presentation regarding the interrelatedness of reading and writing. Your point is right on, I think.
ReplyDeleteI really like your insight that if you give formula - you get formula in responses to text. It is so true and a very thoughtful extension of the point Gallagher is making. On the topic of pleasure reading. I understand Gallagher's emphasis. The reason reading for pleasure is so important is that it develops vocabulary and generic reading strategies (the wide-reading principle) that enable students to read content text. It is no secret in all the studies of testing that students that read more, score higher - across the board. Pleasure reading IS NOT a substitute for reading in your content area. It's all in the balance.
ReplyDeleteYou could not use drama - a little bit of acting out - in your content area? I think you might find that it engages your kinesthetic learners in ways unimaginable ;-) I enjoy the candor and critical quality of your blog!
This blog should be a place to excercise your voice, your opinions. No need to feel at all contrite about this. I am glad you didn't just act as an online yes man/woman for all that is said. In particular, I agree with your accountability point;this is a real need and one that is at times difficult to manage. The one-pager variations seem helpful in addressing that need. One trick we try is a reading role called "artful Adventure"; I expand this role sometimes to a specific artistic medium/method and to small and whole group settings. They must artistically synthesize what they have read into the specific medium: drama, music, diorama, collage, etc. You can make this as detailed or spontaneous as you wish, and set up some backward designed rubrics in advance. Give them the rubric and the text and turn them loose. They love it and class is fun. But the real payoff for both of us is that they demostrate learning, and the standard paper assessment is replaced with a novel approach.
ReplyDeleteI like that you were honest in saying teaching "Hamlet" so that its purpose would be accesible to your students wasn't what you could do just yet. I feel your pain. I think that as students who became teachers, if were taught the classics in such a manner to gain something from it in the first place, we would be in a better position to teach them to our students, presently. But what I have found is through reading and research in order to understand the classics better myself, I can teach the classics so that my students get what was originally intended for them to get out of them in the first place. I just have to do some work myself and fill in my own gaps. YOU CAN DO IT, TOO!
ReplyDeleteI love the one pager idea as well. this is definitely something I can do in my accounting classes.
ReplyDelete