
To me, the description of the sweet spot in teaching the reading made perfect sense because it's what I'm trying to achieve. I'm not trying to get the students to have the surface level understanding and be able to outline the plot, identify the characters, etc. I want them to know why we're studying that particular text. What makes it special? Not good, but special. I think part of what we have to teach is that, while each text might not be your personal preference, the books, poems and short stories that have lasted for so long have done so for a reason that goes beyond that they are "good." I need to have my students explore what that reason is and delve into the deeper themes in the literature and connect it to what's happening currently that's similar.
Gallagher's strategies in this chapter seem very good too, especially when trying to focus on not teaching a book to death. I particularly liked his idea of big chunk/little chunk, and thought in doing so the reader would kind of be doing the second draft reading as well. This strategy appealed to me because the student can read the whole text, but it allows you to focus on the most important parts in class.
I have a bit of an issue with it though, only because it seems unrealistic to me, when combined with the 50-50 reading. That's a lot of reading that would be going on outside class, and while I know Gallagher has gotten to where he has established this in his classroom, with my struggling readers, I would want to tackle one goal at a time. Further, we generally have only a class set of novels, so there would be no option for taking books home, but I know that Gallagher mentioned that earlier in the book as a problem that school's cause because reader flow can't be developed if it takes that long to read the books.
Overall, though, I agree whole-heartedly with his idea of finding the "sweet spot" in teaching reading. It actually jives well with the research that I found about teaching writing and about how it was much more effective to teach writing, and get in the barracks with the students and help them break down the process and begin to think, rather than assign writing and give them feedback afterward. Similarly, his finding the sweetspot requires a teacher to teach reading, and really get the student to explore it, but not take all the control and assign it to them and then analyze it for them.
I will end this week's blog with my favorite quote from this week's reading, "Let's not forget there is beauty and value in reading difficult literature. Our job is to lead our reluctant readers to discover this beauty and value" (94).

I love your perspective on the selected reading for this week. I agree with you that I want my student's reading experiences to be special not good. As an elementary level teacher, we just touch the surface of becoming critical readers, however, I am motivated to try to get below the surface this year. I think the video we watched for this module is a great example of getting to the "Sweet Spot" of reading instruction. I think all reading teachers should be required to read Readicide as a way that as a whole we can reduce readicide and as a method for producing quality reading instruction.
ReplyDeleteGreat visual! Puts that sweet spot into perspective. I think you have something with your final quote. Challenging literature takes effort and sometimes hard work. Perhaps we need to find ways that students experience this effort as personally rewarding.
ReplyDeleteI can see your point about the amount of reading that we expect of students outside the classroom. With a number of teachers all assigning homework, it is easy for students to get overwhelmed with work. Then, frustration and discouragement occurs. How does your school help oversee amount of homework given to students?