The above quote is my favorite from the podcast, but you could probably apply it to Kelly Gallagher's Readicide or to Fisher & Frey's Improving Adolescent Literature. Clearly, all of the authors, like the podcaster(?) agree that students are currently vocabulary deficient, and the authors are determined to give new ideas on how to advance vocabulary.
Gallagher's opinion clearly is that this will not occur unless students are reading for fun. Because of the massive difference in social capital between our students, Gallagher points out, from The Proust and the Squid: The Story of Science and the Reading Brain by Maryanne Wolf, "the young middle -class child hears 32 million more words than the young underpriviledged child by age five"(p. 20). Gallagher further points out that the same student would be three grade levels behind by sixth grade (p. 32). One can't just ignore this issue, especially when the results are so apparent in our society. Those with social capital still dominate in education. It is apparent that the schools in lower socio-economic areas begin with more of a struggling group and continue to struggle throughout their educational career, so why are these systems not focusing on reading so strongly from the beginning if the answer is that obvious? If anything, I have seen my school move it's focus away from reading in the past few years and toward math because those test scores are the struggling test scores. To me the comparison of the athlete that does not perform on game day without practice or the pianist that does not perform with out practice was so poignant because that's exactly what we're asking our students to do, we're taking to them to the big game, test day, with warm ups only, and maybe some scrimmage games, but not any practices. Reading for fun could be that practice, but we're more concerned with addressing everything else in the school.

Vocabulary is not the only deficiency that Gallagher expresses concern for though. He points out that because students aren't reading outside the required texts, they're losing civic engagement and basic knowledge that most adults take for granted. Thus, we have students with "endangered minds." I found this to be troubling too be because while these aspects of the curriculum are often not in the standards until a civics class in high school, these are probably the most important to being productive later in life.
To me, the podcast and IAL seemed to tie in really well together for giving ideas on how to effectively teach vocabulary. My favorite idea from the podcast was the idea of taking the students to Webster's new words list, and having them create their own new word lists. Students and young people tend to be on the forefront of new word creation, so this is a great way to introduce them to both vocabulary and using vivid verbs in writing. All of the vocabulary activities in IAL seemed very helpful as well, and the authors pointed this out about a game, but I would think it would hold true to these activities as well, that you wouldn't want to use them too often or they'd lose their effectiveness. That's why it is so important that there's a variety of useful vocabulary activities. I thought the word sort was a great, hands on way to let the students work through how the words related to each other and not just what they meant. Further, it is a great time for them to make connections that they might not have been willing to point out in a full-class discussion.
Because I teach Language Arts, vocabulary plays a major role in my curriculum, it is one of my standards, and I plan to try to incorporate as many of these methods as possible. I have tried one of them before, but began to rely on it as a crutch for my creative vocabulary instruction. I am excited to try the multiple meanings organizer activity that was discussed, where the students then find and teach a word with multiple meanings. I think that the more hands-on these activities are, the more ownership of the vocabulary the students will take. My biggest hope for introducing these activities into my classroom is that the students will not only improve their understanding of words, but will begin to use them in their writing.

I think that most schools have taken the focus off of reading and placed it solely on test preparation. The idea of using Webster's new words list was a great suggestion. I feel that by allowing our students to create their own new words list everyone would benefit. There are plenty of new slang terms that are completely lost on me. I agree that the more hands on we make activities for students then the more ownership students will take. If the students feel they are in charge of their learning it will become more relevant to them and they should also retain more of the knowledge. I too hope to incorporate many of the methods listed in our assigned reading.
ReplyDeleteListening to the podcast on Class Act and the suggested strategies, I find that I do alot of these, however, at the elementary level, we just touch the surface on content vocabulary. Primarily our focus is on test preparation and reading comprehension stratgies that we do not spend as much time on content vocabulary. One strategy mentioned I am interested in trying next year, is co-teaching with our ESOL teacher and finding the similarities and differences between two languages to help our ELL students. I agree that there are alot of multiple meaning stratgies that I would like to implement with my vocabulary development next year. I am actually thinking about implementing a vocabulary lesson a day...we'll see how it goes.
ReplyDeleteThe quote you begin with struck a cord with me as well. When I was in high school we were given a list of terms and told we would be quizzed on them in a few days. There was no connection of the words to the material or to previous knowledge. I know that had my teachers focused on a few words a day and actually covered those words in depth I would have grasped the words more fully.
ReplyDeleteMichael Graves, who has devoted most of his career to vocabulary research, reveals that we learn a small percentage of our words from direct instruction. Teachers can reasonably teach about 300 words a year. Most of the new vocabulary we acquire is from wide-reading and our experiences. Another reason that Readicide is a vicious cycle. If kids aren't reading - they also aren't developing vocabulary for reading comprehension. I think you include some great ideas in your blog for focusing on vocabulary. I especially think writing is a way to develop vocabulary that we sometimes overlook.
ReplyDeleteYou seemed to have learned alot of stratgies that you can use in your classroom to make your students more successful. I also believe that welath/poverty plays important part of education. I thought that the concept of "word poverty" was amazing. Thirty two million words is alot. School systems seem to have forgotten about teaching reponsibility and character. Hopefully, the higher ups will make changes so that we create well rounded students who are responsible, hard working, informed, and competent citizens of society.
ReplyDelete