Thursday, June 17, 2010

Reflecting on our Initial Readings



As I began to read Gallagher's Readicide, I was shaking my head, partially in agreement and, sadly, partially in disappointment with myself. I'm an English Language Arts teacher, and I know that he is speaking the truth. As I was reading the introduction (though it was not a part of the assigned reading), I stopped when I read the sentence, "educators are more interested in developing lifelong readers than in developing short-term test takers" (p. 4). Before he even had to expand on this, I knew that this simply was not the case anymore. I am not questioning the intentions of any educators, but the output that I have experience with, and this includes my own is more directed toward what Gallagher deems as shallow.

When Gallagher illustrated all of the standards in place in a Social Studies classroom, it was difficult not to cringe, but then think about the Language Arts classroom that has standards in Reading, Writing and Conventions. It is no wonder that there is no longer time to teach novels or when they are being taught, they are being taught at the end of the year.

One of the aspects that I have always found interesting about test prep that Gallagher did not fail to mention is that those who do well on tests rarely need test prep. They are generally so far beyond the basic skills understanding of standardized test that test prep is beneath their level of comprehension. He highlighted this difference by contrasting a multiple choice question with an essay question that answered the same question and then asked why, how do you know, and asked the students to provide evidence. If students were regularly asked to do this higher order thinking rather than bubble in answer sheets and practice questions that look like the test questions then when the test questions were presented, they would easily be able to access the knowledge.

As I moved from Readicide, which I found to be incredibly engaging and a very quick read to Improving Adolescent Literacy, I was pleasantly surprised because it was more of a textbook for teachers. Readicide is more of a call to action. As I was reading it, I immediately recognized what I was doing wrong, and felt impassioned not only to correct my issues but to alert my school and district as to the complex problems that we were going to face if we continued to focus on this shallow understanding of reading. On the other hand, as I read through IAL, I was given useful tools on how to incorporate reading effectively into my classroom, even as a a Language Arts teacher.

One of the biggest challenges that I face as a newer Language Arts teacher is that it is frequently assumed that you just know how to teach a particular aspect of reading or writing, but Language Arts teachers need just as much help with teaching these rather dense concepts as any other content because these are some of the areas in which students are the most reluctant. For me, chapter one was all a repeat of things that I teach, so there was not a lot of new information, but there were some interesting ideas on how to use it, especially when it came to the questions for metacognitive awareness. Though I think giving my students that many questions every time my bog them down, I could likely narrow down the list to get to the point of what I want them to know with one to two questions each.

Chapter two was an awesome reinforcement of things that I had seen before in my initial certification classes, but have not had as much time to visit other than a few failed attempts to practice. What I found most helpful here was that our authors provided diagrams and the role sheet for reciprocal teaching. Interestingly, reciprocal teaching is the one method in this chapter that I had not heard of before. I say this is interesting because it very much looks like it would be the most effective.

I look forward to continuing both books and learning from each of them, and I hope I get over my sense of shame as I continue to read through Readicide.

2 comments:

  1. You are not alone, I was shaking my head as I read the statitics too! I enjoyed reading your second paragraph about the length of the standards. Literacy seems so important, but when the bell of the school year rings to start, educators won't admit that Literacy takes a backseat to standards any weekday. But the real heart of the issue is that these events should not be mutually eclusive, but rather go hand in hand.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am interested in your observation about those students that are beyond the test prep, Jessica. My belief is that if we give students high-challenge, critical thinking tasks throughout the year, we will be supporting the kind of thinking that will make kids more successful on end of grade/year tests. So, instead of drill and kill, we need to design problem-solving and critical thinking tasks that encourage students to think deeply about text. I like the way you recognize the importance of metacognitive awareness. The more we can encourage kids to think about their reading, the more independent and resourceful readers they will become. Enjoyed your blog, Jessica!

    ReplyDelete